By Jessica Monroe · 11 min read · Rating: 4.6/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ · Keyword: The Loaded Tea Shop vs 4C Energy Rush
Jessica Monroe
Health & Wellness Writer · Drank both side by side for a week · Reviewed for accuracy by a registered dietitian
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Consult a healthcare professional before making major changes to your caffeine intake.
Table of Contents
- What an Expert Says About Reading the Label
- Two Very Different Ideas of “Clean Energy”
- Quick Overview: What Each Brand Actually Is
- Head-to-Head Comparison
- Drinking Both Side by Side for a Week
- Where Each Brand Actually Wins
- Things to Know Before You Pick
- Who Should Choose Which
- Maybe Wait If…
- Final Verdict
- FAQ
“The key to avoiding synthetic dyes is to read food labels, take note of the foods you usually purchase that have dye in them and find a dye-free alternative… Look for foods that use natural food coloring from fruit and vegetable extracts.”
— Julia Zumpano, RD, LD, registered dietitian, Cleveland Clinic (via health.clevelandclinic.org)
That advice maps directly onto this comparison: 4C Energy Rush's Strawberry flavor lists Red 40 and Blue 1 on the label, while The Loaded Tea Shop's entire 40+ flavor lineup skips artificial dyes altogether — the FDA has also announced plans to phase out Red 40 by the end of 2026, which makes this comparison timely.
Two Very Different Ideas of “Clean Energy”
4C Energy Rush has been sitting on grocery store shelves for years — cheap, familiar, and easy to grab on a Target run. The Loaded Tea Shop is the newer, online-only alternative that's been all over TikTok. Both claim to be a “clean” caffeine option, but they're built on genuinely different formulas. I bought both, read every ingredient label side by side, and drank them for a week to see how the marketing held up.
Quick Overview: What Each Brand Actually Is
The Loaded Tea Shop
A direct-to-consumer brand selling single-serve loaded tea powder packets across 40+ flavors. Each packet makes 32 ounces, delivers 200mg of natural green tea caffeine, and is zero calories, zero sugar, zero carbs, with no artificial colors.
4C Energy Rush
A grocery-store staple drink mix stick sized for a 16.9-ounce water bottle. It's sugar-free but not calorie-free, uses synthetic caffeine plus taurine, includes electrolyte ingredients like potassium and sodium citrate, and comes in a smaller lineup of flavors, some of which contain artificial dyes.
Want the dye-free option with 40+ flavors instead of 8? See why so many people are switching.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Category | The Loaded Tea Shop | 4C Energy Rush |
|---|---|---|
| Serving size | 32 oz per packet | 16.9 oz per packet |
| Caffeine | 200mg, natural (green tea) | ~150-200mg, synthetic |
| Calories | 0 | ~15 |
| Carbs / Sugar | 0g / 0g | ~4g / 0g |
| Artificial colors | None, any flavor | Some flavors (Red 40, Blue 1, Yellow 5) |
| Electrolytes | Not marketed as electrolyte drink | Yes — potassium, sodium, calcium citrate |
| Flavor count | 40+ | ~6-8 |
| Price per packet | $3.00-4.00 (bulk) | ~$0.50-0.65 |
| Where to buy | Online only (DTC) | Walmart, grocery stores |
Drinking Both Side by Side for a Week
Day 1: The First Taste Test
I mixed 4C's orange flavor in a 16.9oz bottle and The Loaded Tea Shop's Bahama Mama in a 32oz cup, back to back. 4C tasted noticeably more tart and “powdery,” closer to a classic Crystal Light with a caffeine kick. Bahama Mama tasted sweeter and more like a flavored soda replacement. The caffeine hit from 4C came on faster — likely because it's concentrated in half the liquid.
Days 2–4: Living With Both
By day 3, the practical differences started mattering more than taste. I could grab 4C from my local grocery store the same afternoon I ran out, while my Loaded Tea Shop order took two days to arrive by mail. On the flip side, I got bored of 4C's flavor options by day 3 — there are really only a handful of core flavors — while I hadn't even made it through half of my Loaded Tea Shop variety pack.
Days 5–7: The Value Check
I did the math at the end of the week. 4C genuinely came out cheaper per ounce, even accounting for the smaller serving size. But when I checked the ingredient labels again, the Strawberry 4C flavor I'd grabbed had Red 40 and Blue 1 listed, which I hadn't clocked until I looked closely — something I never had to think about with any Loaded Tea Shop flavor.
Where Each Brand Actually Wins
- 4C wins on price and access. It's cheaper per ounce and you can buy it at a physical store today instead of waiting on shipping.
- 4C wins on electrolytes. If you specifically want a hydration/electrolyte angle alongside caffeine, 4C's formula is built for that.
- The Loaded Tea Shop wins on ingredient transparency. Zero artificial colors across the entire catalog, versus dyes in some 4C flavors.
- The Loaded Tea Shop wins on true zero-calorie status. 4C's “sugar-free” label doesn't mean calorie-free or carb-free.
- The Loaded Tea Shop wins on variety. 40+ flavors versus 4C's much smaller core lineup.
Things to Know Before You Pick
- The Loaded Tea Shop costs more per ounce, even factoring in the bigger serving size — you're paying for the flavor variety and dye-free formula.
- 4C's dye-free flavors do exist — Orange and Berry are typically the safer picks if you want to avoid Red 40 or Yellow 5 without switching brands entirely.
- Shipping wait time is real for The Loaded Tea Shop — if you need caffeine today, a store shelf beats a 1-2 day shipping window.
Who Should Choose Which
Choose 4C Energy Rush if you want the cheapest possible option, need it from a physical store today, or specifically want the added electrolytes. Choose The Loaded Tea Shop if avoiding artificial dyes is a priority, you want a genuinely zero-calorie option, or you're the type of person who wants 40 flavors to rotate through instead of the same 3-4 options every week.
Maybe Wait If…
If you're on a tight grocery budget and caffeine source or dye content isn't a major concern for you, 4C's lower price per ounce is hard to argue with — there's no need to switch just for the sake of it. And if you need same-day access to caffeine regularly, factor in The Loaded Tea Shop's shipping window before committing to it as your only option.
Final Verdict: 4.6/5
4C Energy Rush isn't a bad product — it's cheap, widely available, and does what it says. But once I lined up the ingredient labels side by side, The Loaded Tea Shop's combination of natural caffeine, genuinely zero-calorie formula, and dye-free lineup across 40+ flavors made it the one I kept reaching for by the end of the week, even at a higher price per ounce.
If your top priority is price and convenience, 4C wins fair and square. If you're choosing based on what's actually in the packet, The Loaded Tea Shop is the stronger pick.
Ready to try the dye-free, zero-calorie option with 40+ flavors?
Backed by the 30-day Loaded Promise — if you don't love it, they'll make it right.
FAQ
Is The Loaded Tea Shop or 4C Energy Rush cheaper?
Per packet, 4C Energy Rush is cheaper at roughly $0.50 to $0.65 a packet versus $3.00 to $4.00 for The Loaded Tea Shop. But 4C's packet is sized for a 16.9-ounce bottle while The Loaded Tea Shop's packet makes a full 32 ounces, so the real per-ounce gap is smaller than the sticker price suggests, even though 4C still comes out cheaper overall.
Which has more caffeine, The Loaded Tea Shop or 4C Energy Rush?
Both land around 150-200mg per packet depending on the source and flavor, so they're comparable in total caffeine. The bigger difference is concentration: 4C delivers its caffeine in about half the liquid, so it can feel like a stronger, faster hit per sip, while The Loaded Tea Shop's dose is spread across a full 32 ounces.
Does 4C Energy Rush contain artificial dyes?
Some flavors do. The Strawberry flavor lists FD&C Red 40 and FD&C Blue 1, and the Citrus flavor lists FD&C Yellow 5. The Loaded Tea Shop, by contrast, doesn't use any artificial colors across its full 40+ flavor lineup.
Can I buy 4C Energy Rush in stores?
Yes, that's one of its biggest advantages. 4C Energy Rush is sold at Walmart and regional grocery chains, so you can pick it up same-day. The Loaded Tea Shop is direct-to-consumer online only, which means planning ahead for shipping.
Which one is truly zero-calorie?
The Loaded Tea Shop is genuinely zero calories, zero carbs, and zero sugar across its lineup. 4C Energy Rush is sugar-free but not calorie-free — it runs about 15 calories and 4 grams of carbs per packet.
Does 4C Energy Rush have electrolytes, and does The Loaded Tea Shop?
4C Energy Rush is formulated with potassium citrate, sodium citrate, and calcium citrate, and markets itself partly as a hydration/electrolyte product, with about 330mg of sodium per packet. The Loaded Tea Shop isn't marketed as an electrolyte drink and doesn't make hydration-specific claims.
Which has more flavor options?
The Loaded Tea Shop, by a wide margin. It offers 40+ flavors compared to 4C Energy Rush's much smaller core lineup of around 6-8 flavors like orange, citrus, berry, strawberry, and grape.
Which one should I actually buy?
If price and grabbing it at a physical store matter most, 4C Energy Rush wins. If you care about avoiding artificial dyes, want true zero-calorie, or want a much bigger flavor selection, The Loaded Tea Shop is the better fit, even at a higher per-ounce price.
Top Picks